Gender Perspective in the Criminal Procedure

Refutation? of some conjectures held in Ramirez Ortiz paper's «Single Victim’s Testimony and Gender Perspective in the Criminal Procedure»

Authors

Abstract

The present paper does not intend to refute -in the strict sense- the theses held in the research work of RAMIREZ ORTIZ, «Single victim’s testimony and gender perspective in the criminal procedure». The purpose is to introduce some nuances that explain the role that the gender perspective will play not only in the whole criminal process but, specifically, in relation to the uncorroborated single testimony. I agree with the author of reference that the gender perspective cannot fill situations of evident insufficiency –like the uncorroborated single testimony- but there are many other contributions that can be incorporated into the assessment of this testimony. In fact, as it will be held, the gender perspective applied to the assessment of the victim's testimony and to the corroboration of certain of its peripheral elements, will prevent a large number of uncorroborated single testimonies, which conclude in acquital.

Keywords

single victim’s testimony, victim statement, corroboration, presumption of innocence, gender perspective, evaluation of the evidence, body of evidence

References

Fuentes Soriano, O., 2000: «Valoración de la prueba indiciaria y declaración de la víctima en los delitos sexuales», en Problemas actuales de la administración de justicia en los delitos sexuales, Perú: Edit. Defensoría del Pueblo: 151-249.

García Porres,, I., y Subijana Zunzunegui, I., 2018: «El enjuiciamiento penal con perspectiva de género», SEPIN, SP/DOCT/75846 (septiembre): 1-13.

Nieva Fenoll, J., 2007: Enjuiciamiento prima facie. Aproximación al elemento psicológico de las decisiones judiciales, Barcelona: Atelier.

Ramírez Ortiz, J.L., 2019: «El testimonio único de la víctima en el proceso penal desde la perspectiva de género», en Quaestio facti. Revista internacional sobre razonamiento probatorio (núm. 51): 1-45.

Author Biography

Olga Fuentes Soriano, Universidad Miguel Hernández

Catedrática de derecho procesal Universidad Miguel Hernández

DOI

https://doi.org/10.33115/udg_bib/qf.i0.22372

Published

2020-01-28

How to Cite

Fuentes Soriano, O. (2020). Gender Perspective in the Criminal Procedure: Refutation? of some conjectures held in Ramirez Ortiz paper’s «Single Victim’s Testimony and Gender Perspective in the Criminal Procedure». Quaestio Facti. International Journal on Evidential Reasoning, (1), 271–284. https://doi.org/10.33115/udg_bib/qf.i0.22372